In this, my first substack video, I react to the shameful encounter between American leaders and media and the Ukrainian president. No doubt there were more, but I saw five failures on our side: of hospitality, decency, democracy, strategy, and independence. Please watch and share.
If you are thinking today about how to help Ukrainians, here are some possibilities: Come Back Alive (Ukrainian NGO that supports soldiers on the battlefield and veterans), United 24 (the Ukrainian state platform for donations, with many excellent projects), RAZOM (an American NGO, tax-deductible for US citizens, which cooperates with Ukrainian NGOS to support civilians), and Documenting Ukraine (a project that helps to give Ukrainians a voice, also tax-deductible for Americans).
I am seething with rage. 😡 As the granddaughter of a veteran who fought at Normandy on D-Day, I am so deeply ashamed that this POS has disgraced the memories of those we lost and every American alive today and our freedom fighters here and abroad with this disgusting act of propaganda engineered to hide the weakness of an American president and his inability to govern. It’s unforgivable. Everyone, donate what you can to United24 and give to the Ukrainian cause, then find a protest and stand with Ukraine! 🇺🇦
Yes! And to think that this year we will commemorate the end of WWII in Europe...I don't see how Trump can show his face. He has deeply damaged us at home and around the world. That would have been an event where we could have been acknowledged and appreciated as good guys and strengthen our current alliances. Trump has trashed all that.
Tramp most likely will travel to moscow to celebrate
You've expressed so well the deep, deep shame and disgust we all feel regarding Trump's and Vance's despicable, shameful behavior, and toward a legitimate world leader. Ukraine was viciously and wantonly attacked unprovoked by Russia. Do T and V have absolutely no humanity in their hearts and souls toward a country whose children, women, grandparents, etc. were savagely attacked and murdered by Russia. Who are these demons????
I have been giving to https://rolda.org/breaking-news-ukraine/ So many abandoned animals
Thank you for helping the voiceless who suffer in huge numbers as no one else does. Also, you can have a look at PETA and a few others rescuing animals from a front line
Yes. My Dad was not at D-Day but both of my parents joined the U.S. Army in 1942 and my first memories are of war-torn German in the 1950s. TOTAL DISRESPECT is what enraged me first today.
I have been donating to RAZOM and just did so a couple of days ago.
All set. Thanks.
Done. Thank you.
What's RAZOM?
It is a nonprofit suggested by Dr. Snyder. https://www.razomforukraine.org/
Just donated
Yes, donated tonight with hopes that every citizen of the US who is able, does too🇺🇦
me, too!!!
Thank you. I just did.
Same here. Disgusted, and my mother and father-in-law fought in WWII in Europe. It makes me nauseous what these "leaders" of the US are doing.
Tell me where WE who find so much pain in this moment for Ukrainians can give to a fund that shows WE stand with them. I would like a "go fund me" type place that shows our particular revulsion of what happened in OUR OVAL office with thuggish trump/vance. It would be our chance to show our RESISTANCE now and always for countries that are invaded to be dominated by dictators.
Dr. Snyder recommended RAZOM after Russia invaded Ukraine. 4 out of 4 stars on Charity Navigator. https://www.razomforukraine.org/
Check the sites for more info.
How to SAY WE are sorry to Zelensky/Ukraine? DONATE! Both of these are fully tax deductible if you itemize IRS deductions.
Razom for Ukraine
United 24 or
"The official partner of UNITED24 in US is Ukraine House DC Foundation, a 501(c)3 registered nonprofit organization (EIN 872080907)" -Wiki
Thank you for the lead. This charity is fully tax deductible on itemized deductions for IRS filing. (501)(c)(3)
United24, the President's Initiative, lets you donate directly to Ukraine's defense, donate to rebuild Ukraine, or to several other great Ukraine causes. I believe the url is u24.gov.ua
How to SAY WE are sorry to Zelensky/Ukraine? DONATE! Both of these are fully tax deductible if you itemize IRS deductions.
Razom for Ukraine
United 24 or
"The official partner of UNITED24 in US is Ukraine House DC Foundation, a 501(c)3 registered nonprofit organization (EIN 872080907)" -Wiki
Thank you. I'll check it out.
compassion Connection UA is a nonprofit 501 organization supplying goods to to support Ukraine
Thank you, Charles.
Copied from Timothy Snyder’s 3/1 post:
If you are thinking today about how to help Ukrainians, here are some possibilities: Come Back Alive, a Ukrainian NGO that supports soldiers on the battlefield and veterans; United 24, the Ukrainian state platform for donations, with many excellent projects); RAZOM, an American NGO, tax-deductible for US citizens, which cooperates with Ukrainian NGOS to support civilians; and BlueCheck Ukraine, which aims for efficient cooperation with Ukrainian groups and is also tax-deductible.
so great, thanks.
Did you hear that a Norwegian refueler of military ships refuses to fill USA ships because of Zelensky's horrible treatment? Haltbakk Bunkers I will take resisers from anywhere. People who put the money where their mouth is have added admirations.
Have a peaceful night. emoji, emoji
in california, its hard to find a protest near me. is there a list ?
I was outraged when I watched the excoriation of President Zelenskyy by two of the most disgusting people who have ever been in power in the U.S. After listening to you, however, I am surprised to find tears rolling down my face. I realize that I am grieving the death of my country.
I've been crying for hours, and I'm not even American.
((( ))) As an American, thank you.
Agree totally. As an American, I am proud to be your fellow citizen.
And I, yours.
That is exactly how I'm feeling! I am so ashamed to be an American, I am so very thankful for Timothy Snyder.
I just started crying because deep down my anger is really fear of feeling the grief of the death of an amazing idea, 250 years old, that allowed us self-rule. Though never perfect, it held out hope that one day.....
I cannot think of this grief again because I must use every day to RESIST with "blood, sweat and tears" until my death.
Your last thought “saying the quiet part out loud.”
Your courage is appreciated.
Why do you think the country has died?
Fascists, anti-Constitutionalists, and a dictator have almost all of the power now.
Keep an image of the final days of Mussolini in your mind.
Yes, but the fact that it took such a long, long time, and a more than a million deaths, does not console me.
Nothing will. But some of the most evil men end badly. Hitler died miserably in a bunker and his generals wanted to kill him. At this point I feel I have a tiny fist waving in the air. But King Farouk of Egypt, in exile in Italy I believe, ate himself to death. Maybe that will be more accurate.
80,000,000 people died by the time Hitler committed suicide. That's no consolation. (And his generals failed.)
There is of course little consolation. I know the generals failed. But there is a bit of consolation that these evil people eventually die. If there were no end to it ever ( and it is often that way or it seems that way) there would be no point in going on, yet people like Vaclev Havel, George Washington, Nelson Mandela and Martin Luther King persisted. Perhaps our species is irredeemable. Then nothing can be accomplished.
You are so right about the heroes who "never gave up". (That's H.H. the Dalai Lama's motto, BTW. He's another great hero.) You got me thinking: at least, generally, not all of the monsters are alive in all of the places at the same time. That's a good thing. (I'm related to von Stauffenberg, one of the generals who left the bomb to kill Hitler. As you know, it tragically failed.)
I am wondering where are generals are now. I’m also wondering if this dangerous buffoon will collapse like the Hindenburg or something is afoot.
"Our" generals? Well, we know that the decimation has begun. I believe that the military will become the orange sadist's weapon to be used against us. Unfortunately I can never think of the orange sadist as a buffoon. He's far too dangerous for any word that has a connotation of humor.
Facebook “news” feed is the fast track to fascism.
Maybe future historians will easily see, how over just two decades, it was Facebook newsfeed that caused world war 3.
Do you like the answers?
No.
Thank you for articulating these points so clearly. I can tell by your affect and demeanor how gravely confounding you find the present state of American politics. Please continue to create videos like this one. I appreciate your contributions.
How beautifully stated. ❤️
Here's an idea.
This Tues he'll be speaking to the joint session of Congress and there will be millions and millions of people watching. Dems can do civil disobedience. After each lie, one by one, they can stand up and turn their backs to him. Soon, many will be standing and can shout "Stop the Steal" or sing the national anthem... They can hold the floor and interrupt the coronation just like he tried to do on J6. He will be shamed and we know he'll respond badly, despicably.
He will be exposed as the weak pitiful man he is and his party will also be rebuked.
Who can initiate this action? Bernie? AOC? Murphy? Crockett?
Certainly not Schumer or Jeffries who should get the hell out of the way and let the strong people take the lead. If Dems sit meekly by, then capitulation will be complete in the eyes of the world and Dems will have abandoned us again.
Thoughts
there are protests again this Tuesday March 4 in every state #50501
https://www.fiftyfifty.one/
Sorry for cross-posting but wanted to reply to your suggestion, Anne. First, I love it! Symbolic gestures DO matter! Let's keep the creative ideas coming, and people will act on the best of them. In that spirit, I suggested the following to Senator Schumer (one of my senators) and a similar one to my NY Representative. I would love to hear people’s thoughts about it! And we certainly don't need to wait to wait for this or that leader, as you say, but some leadership is needed!
Senator Schumer,
With our federal laws and even our Constitution being violated by a rogue President, now is the time for you and your fellow Democrats and Independents (and any Republicans who have the courage) to lead in the resistance. We need a strong statement, one that is symbolic, impactful, AND feasible.
So here is my suggestion: a Liberty Torch relay to Washington, D.C. that passes through villages, towns, cities, and suburbs on its way to D.C. via state capitals, with perhaps a scheduled "arrival" in D.C. on July 4th. There would be a statement on the torch reaffirming commitment to uphold and protect the Constitution of the United States, and then there would be a digital mechanism, perhaps using blockchain technology, for Americans to electronically sign their name to that statement. This would enable Americans to sign onto the statement without having to physically attend the relay. And the torch would be not one torch but 435 torches that start in the Congressional districts and make their way to their state capital. If blockchain is used, then with each signature, the blockchain gets longer. As these torches are relayed there would be opportunities for ceremonies to receive and pass on the torch, with marches and caravans along the way.
From each state capital, a caravan of that state's torches would then drive to Washington D.C. An "app" could be set up to enable Americans to track the relay of the torches along with signatures as they came in. PSAs and local and national media would track the spectacle. There would then be a grand Constitutional lighting ceremony in Washington D.C. attended by Congressional and civil leaders to receive the 435 torches where they would be displayed. Each Senator and House Representative, Supreme Court Justice, and the President would then be called on to reaffirm their commitment, per their oath of office, to support and defend the Constitution of the United States by signing a federal version of the torch.
A nonresponse to these historically unprecedented attacks on our Constitution and underlying democratic norms would reinforce these attacks by implicitly accepting them. Our hand is forced. The time for action--to say that this in not normal or acceptable--is now.
Please let me know what you think. I stand ready to help make something like this happen.
Thank you,
Stephan Brown
Great idea Stephan. That would matter to people and cut through the murk in a more personal way. We are all patriotic when we fight for our country.
I agree with you one hundred percent. I have forwarded your suggestion to my Congresswoman and both of my Senators, and I urge every who reads this to do the same.
Thanks for sending it on. If everyone sent it to 5 people...
Especially after today's fiasco, the Dems are obligated to take a public stand to rebuke them and stand for decency.
If the Dems do stop the joint session, do you think they can be forced to stop once they start? I dont think so.
Yes. They must do Something!
Thank you for suggesting this! I will share your idea widely!
Good! Let’s push them to do something there. Not some gathering in front of the cameras outside on the steps making pronouncements. Public action. If people see them lead the way in taking risk I bet it will encourage US to get out there and do the same.
I like this idea. I had an idea the other day regarding the 12 year old at the press podium saying they would pick and choose news outlets; what if no one showed up? Effectively a news media boycott. The admin would wither without the media reporting, especially president Cartman. just a thought
Yes, another good idea! What legacy news outlet would have the guts to do that?
Thanks to the people who like my idea. Consequently it was shot down by Peter Baker on "The Weekend" last Sunday. He said getting all the press to do that would be like herding cats. Even if it did happen all the seats would be refilled by supporters, just like they do at rallies. Oh well.
Now, I had another idea: I am always speaking to the TV when I see good information on, for instance, MSNBC; I am saying "The information you are putting out is like speaking to the choir. These pieces need to be on FOX, etc.
Apparently that cannot or will not be done.
So, the idea is to make a list of all the twitter (or FB) handles of Pulican Senators and Congressional reps. Then take the links from these great Substack pieces and post them on the sites of the people on the list. That way there would be good information in all these feeds that maybe, maybe, might be read. In order to add more of the handles to each post, saving time, one could use one of the shortening services on the links: Tinyurl, Bitly, Short.io, Rebrandly, or Dub. Might work, might not? What say you Peter? ;-)))))))))))
Thanks Joel.
My Rep., Jim McGovern said in a town hall recently, that we should all share our ideas widely because you never know which idea will go viral and be the spark for change and They Need Ideas. So… Keep spreading your ideas around. It inspires everyone else and we’ll just keep showing up everywhere.
Outstanding idea! EVERYONE MUST CONTACT your MOCs and encourage this kind of protest on Tuesday. The Dems must act and act with force.
Infuriating and embarrassing.. truly despicable
YES Carol!! President Trump and JD Vance were despicable. I immediately called my Republican Representative in Congress and said I want him to speak out against Trump and Vance and their disrespectful treatment of President Zelensky. Trump sounded like Putin! Disgusting!
I did the same.
These are good things to do and I have been doing them, but now we the people, for the people, by the people, must take our country back.
Putin, yes but also like a man who grabs a female "pussy" because he thinks he has the right. I'm sure he forced children to have sex with him and assaulted many females. He is an insecure, fat, ugly thing who cannot feel secure until he controls, bullies, forces someone to do his bidding. He is a convicted felon, sexual assaulter and a dangerous threat to the world and our country. That wealthy people applaud and give in to him is disgusting. They should lose all their wealth for betrayal of 330M people in USA and millions in democratic countries around the world.
I truly hate to think of what I would do with all these traitors to the USA.
So much sadness for Ukraine and Zelynskyy. The US is a rotting corpse.
So it seems.
Speechless, so happy that you can find words to describe this disgrace 😵💫
Yes. I am so grateful that you made this video. I haven't even had the nerve to watch what happened. It's hard for me to look and listen to Trump and Vance under any circumstances, but I've heard enough about it to feel lost. Now, after hearing what you said, I feel less lost. Thank you. I just called my Republican Senator.
First generation Ukrainian American daughter of Partisan here. I sit here with disbelief. Stunned that these two men are Americans, parroting Russian talking points, unaware of where they sit and the legacy of that office, and unaware of the depth of the man at whom they are yelling. Ukrainians understand propaganda. Ukrainians know their history and the past attempts at promises of those who sought only to carve up their country. This is a tipping point. President Zelensky, the Ukrainians, and the EU will prevail. And sadly, America will suffer for all the actions of these broken liars.
Second generation Ukrainian here. My sweet little babushka used to spit on television pictures of Stalin.
Churchill called Stalin "an unnatural man." That's what I think of when I think of Putin, Trump and Vance.
I’m with your babushka. Truth be told - I want to live long enough to piss on Trump’s grave.
Piss away. Sooner rather than later. I understand he falls asleep during the Musk cabinet meetings.
Also second generation Ukrainian. Zelensky is a hero. Trumpovsky and Vanceovskaya are Putin’s lapdogs. My greater fear and concern is how can they be stopped. They are giving Putin access to taking over not only Ukraine, Eastern Europe but also the US. Trump, being a Russian asset, Muskova a thief with who knows what he and Putin are planning, and Vance a yelling Nazi idiot, man wanting to control and berate women including his wife and mother in law. Can they be stopped exposed and convicted of treason? They refuse to obey the laws so other ways will have to be taken to stop them from totally ruining the US.
I am disgusted and embarrassed to be an American. Such a shameful display by Trump/Vance.
Americans are losing their friends and allies everywhere. People have started boycotting anything American. It started with Tesla cars but you can expect it to spread. The United-States have also lost the trust that was built over the years. If Americans don't react they may wake up one morning and find out they have become a colony of the new Chinese-Russian superpower, courtesy of Trump/Musk.
but one good came from the oval office meeting: the Europeans, Japanese, Australians, South Koreans all know what they nerd to do next. Form a democratic coalition without America for there self protection!
Please don't forget Canada.
I hope they exclude America from shared Intel
They will of course exclude us... we are not their alies anymore
Better still fed disinformation. The US should be attacked with all the ferocity the real free world can muster.
I forgot Canada, Mexico and Indonesia and the Philippines🙈. sorry. In the week since the original post, many of these countries have already begun the formation of the "America Out" coalition. And the new world order in formation has a realignment we could not have predicted happening so quickly: China/Iran/north Korea/Amer-Russia/Democratic Countries. New nukes. New rearmament. God save our blue sphere.
An ambush/mob shakedown of an incredibly brave ally. And the throwaway line that it would make good television only showed the shallow vileness of this administration. Thank you for the always excellent analysis.
They don’t know what hospitality means. Trump and his regime are hostile bullies.
I bet Trump and Vance would be very hospitable to Putin.
How in god's name did Putin manage to buy a US administration, twice! And now the Republican Congress.
Have you seen the replies of most Republicans to the 2 questions: Did Russia invade Ukraine in 2022? and Is Vladimir Putin a dictator? in The Atlantic. You had to answer Yes or No. Very few answered the questions. They are afraid...
Putin, with a Saudi boost, helped Elon buy Twitter and AI let Elon know how much cash to spend with Zuck, zeroing in those ads and propaganda in those key districts of swing states. When you have enough money to spend, a proven persuasive algorithm, an addictive dopamine platform, combing personalized propagandist, an amplification device, Twitter, a delivery device Facebook newsfeed, to a pre-selected vulnerable persuadable target ( voter), data analyzing scientists, political technologists, it’s not that hard to manipulate an electoral system that was set up in the early 1800’s to protect a slave holding oligarchical class in the developing country.
It’s not rocket science .
But when you apply rocket science kind of money, technology, educated and driven people, and AI …that’s a powerful mix to getting things done. In this case, taking an election with military grade psychological weapons.
Have you seen the. News articles about the threats to senators’ and congresspeople’s persons and families? Such a dangerous moment. If T actually has someone killed, won’t that stop people from speaking out! Because of their fear, now is the time for them to speak out! And for us to speak out! What are you doing today that is more important than that?
Putin taught Silicon Valley what lesson from 2016?
Thank you for doing this amazing analysis; I just watched a video of the meeting and was completely appalled by the behavior of Trump and Vance. They are an embarrassment to all of us. I'm doing what I can to support Ukraine through United 24.
It was an ambush https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/oval-office-ambush
Is United 24 a safe, genuine way to get money to Ukraine? Can it be a scam?
Definitely not a scam. Prof.Snyder personally sees what they are doing with the money.
They put on such a great show for Putin -he couldn’t have asked for or more.
The champagne corks are popping in Moscow tonight. 🍾🥂
I cannot stop crying. My stomach is retching. My mother was Ukrainian. I used to say a proud Ukrainian American. I can no longer add “American”. The courage Zelenskyy’s exhibited in submitting himself to what can only be called humiliation for the sake of his people showed himself to be the true warrior. Illinois Governor JB Pritzker said “ The best way to spot an idiot, look for the person who is cruel.” Perfect descriptions of Trump and Vance.
I am so glad you speak of Zelensky's courage. You are entirely correct - he is the real warrior. I don't want to use my credit card tonight, but I will donate to Ukraine tomorrow in your mother's honor.
Thank you. She would thank you as do I.
I just donated to Come Back Alive.
5 heartbreaking failures. Thank you for posting live on Substack and yes, please post often. We are now exposed to a terrifying reality.
Their inhumanity puts all Americans at risk. As five former Defense Secretaries recently noted, so does much else of Trump’s “reckless” behavior.
Thank you Professor Snyder. trump is Inept, Rude, Disrespectful. I am ashamed to be an American at this moment. We have leadership in lowercase, who ganged up on President Zelenskyy. trump wanted to extort the minerals and oil from Ukraine. He is a shyster. I see him with bottles marked XXX on the back of a rickety wagon pretending he is offering a wonderful deal. Extremely offended if you disagree with him and don't want to pay his price. Our Allies are going to have to save US. I will always stand with Ukraine.
Thank you for your wise, measured, and truthful words.
Zelensky had all the cards in the room. Trump and Vance had none.
The hardcore MAGAs support them. Vance has already said he doesn’t care about Ukraine. MAGAs agree.
It’s like the isolationism of WW2 before Pearl Harbor, called the “America First” movement.
And they were in close contact with Herr Hitler.
Indeed. But the parallels are there.
Thank you for the video and the timely posting of it. I watched and read the captions instead of listening. (Being forewarned, I had no desire to hear Trump or Vance.) I felt like I was watching a protection-racket shakedown of a man who had been literally watching his friends die for three years. Your analysis may, perhaps, keep me from obsessing about the appalling spectacle. Your identification of the failures is compelling, but I might add a failure of humanity to your list..
Protection-racket shakedown, an Oval office ambush https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/oval-office-ambush
Thank you for this. I’m so embarrassed. This was shameful.
The inflection point at this moment is beyond dire and dangerous. The behavior today of the US president and the vice president in the oval office is putting American lives at risk. The American people and Ukraine are the losers, the only winners today were Putin and Russia. This is a time for all former and current elected officials to come together in a united front to defend American values and American lives. This must happen immediately, we are running out of time.
I'd sure like to hear from Kamala Harris- where IS she?
Why? That ship sailed and sank. Too many drank the poison the republicans fed them. Now the rictus begins.
I agree! Now or perhaps never?
I see this as a planned reality TV double-team rough-up created to be a distraction from the robbery now happening up the street. This is basic gangsterism masked as politics. If we all focus now on Ukraine, the final stages of the digital coup lead by Musk can be fully secured to a point where there is no possible way to go back. There is more to come of similar magnitude I'm sure. Those "rare earth" dollars in Ukraine are up for grabs. The two mob bosses will share those once they get Zelensky out of the way. This is such basic criminality. Half the USA voted in a criminal enterprise to be our government. It's really that simple. We've been set up.
I agree. I don't think Americans will ever be able to find the stolen billions, if they ever try. If there is no regime change that turns the country into a sort of dictatorship for decades.
agree!
Thanks,Doug, for your description of what’s going on.
Despicable.
Thank you Professor Snyder!!! Please do more videos. I trust you and so appreciate your perspective and guidance right now . I am just heartbroken, enraged and disturbed by that despicable performance by Trump and Vance in the Oval Office. So many Americans support Ukraine and admire Zelenskyy.
Thank God to hear your voice just now, Timothy Snyder. Thank you.
Thanks for this. Thoughtful, clear, well-organized . . . .from the head, and underscored by the heart.
❤️
One thing Trump unequivocally proved today...that all those allegations that he calls the "Russia Russia Russia hoax" - were all true. True back then. True today. He was in in Putin's pocket back then and he's in Putin's pocket today, colluding, conspiring and collaborating against the interests of the United States of America and our allies endangering our national security. This is Treason, America, pure and simple Treason. We cannot allow this madness, tyranny and treachery to continue. The time to ACT is NOW.
So true, MJ. Wake up Americans!
Thank you! I’m petrified about the outcome for Ukraine, and ultimately for us.
Agree. Grotesque. T told us it was all for television if you like snuff films.
Thank you, Timothy...that was important for us to hear. I agree with all the comments here...infuriating and embarrassing, and I'll add I am heartsick for Zelensky and Ukraine. He acted with great dignity and calm, making efforts to correct Trump's lies and distortions, holding his own against the bullying. Vance was a repugnant pitbull also.
Thank you, Dr. Snyder. During trump's first term I was frequently embarrassed by hi crude and rude behavior. Today's display of 5th grader's bullying of a person of great dignity and stature was beyond embarrassment. It is a display of shame.
Only Putin gets hospitality...
good analysis as always
Thank you. What can we do?
This was surely a planned show..
Rubio should resign
https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/oval-office-ambush
The information about other economies in relationship to Russia is very informative. We have to get that out there. That's the interesting question of "why" -- aside from Trump's personal financial interest in Russia
I believe that a significant part is psychological. The orange sadist is a stupid man. He worships two things: $$$$$ and power. He sees pukin as enormously powerful. He wants to be like him. He wants pukin to respect him. I think that drives him more than anything else in this situation.
It seems even weirder than this to me - at one point in his mad rant, Trump seemed to be sympathising with PUTIN'S suffering over TRUMP'S impeachment. "We went through a lot together" - does he identify that strongly with Putin? Dangerous state of mind.
WHEW! Now that's a thought I never had. Horrifying!
Yes.
Russian asset.
Understatement
I think he also hates President Zelenskyy for not supporting his lie related to his first Impeachment. He went into a spin about the laptop. Lev Parnas was witness to the laptop story, maybe we will hear him speak up about that again. They thought they they would have a show and come out looking on top. He cannot stand anyone who says NO to him. And President Zelenskyy stood up to him as did Macron. I will watch my words here trump and vance are evil.
And don't forget Musk. The pair is Musk/Vance. They pull the strings.
He loves all dictators, Xi, Kim Jung-un, Putin. He wants to belong to the club, have the power of a dictator and be feared and obeyed. The people around him know it. They flatter him to convince him he’s succeeded and Trump spends his time in front of screens and mirrors admiring himself, when he is not playing golf. This leaves them free to do whatever they please, destroy US democracy, transfer public money into their accounts, racket, steal, blackmail you name it. And it seems most Americans just watch on, thinking it’s the latest episode of a new fun reality show.
trump lived in NYC and regularly worked with Mafia MOB in real estate business. He was a wanna be MOB BOSS and now he is!
You really have to remember where trump lived most of his life. NYC and was in real estate. I lived in CT for decades 90 minutes from NY and some Mafia Mobsters live in a nearby town.
I know the way the MAFIA worked in NYC and have watched enough MOB movies to KNOW that trump wants to be just like a MOB BOSS and thinks he can absorb other MOB BOSS, dictators, around the world to be the biggest SHIT of them all.
Just look at all MAGA, Loyal GOP, Loyal Cabinet Secretaries as part of MOB BOSS Don trump.
There is no camouflage that can hide his ruthlessness, cruelty and stupid belief that he deserves to rule us all.
trump has got to be one of the most uneducated MOB BOSSES but with money buying his way to power-he holds the crown for now.
Bingo!
Because he is a Russian asset. Books have been published on the subject, and not only in English.
Yes, I have a couple of them, myself.
I read that his grand father and his father were members of the mafia. His grand father started investing in brothels when he arrived in the U.S. Then it was real estate. So Trump was brought up in a family where you bought politicians with a prostitute, someone higher up with a flat (apartment). Trump lost a lot of money in the 1980s, the KGB helped him out. He built the Trump Tower and the rich Russian oligarchs invested in luxury flats the money they had stolen in the USSR and later when it collapsed. Trump belongs to the American underworld (to put it nicely). Why did Americans elect such a person? Why can you elect someone without checking his past in the U.S.? Do Americans think that mafiosi are respectable people? Why do Americans tolerate Trump’s pathological lying? Why aren’t Americans frightened by his level of instability, his deep psychological problems? These are some of my numerous questions. I have lived in the U.S., but now I find it is easier to understand how the Russian society works than the American one.
In fact Putin and Trump have the same past. Mafia mobsters both of them.
They don’t care about civility or hospitality. It decency. They don’t care about conventions.
This was all about what they thought was showing strength.
And the media reaction has been mild to say the least.
How about the joker who asked why Zelensky doesn't wear a suit?!!!
That joker was apparently Marjorie Taylor Green's boyfriend, who works for one of the right wing news outlets.
I received an email this morning asking for $ from Kamala
Why everyone keeps applying the rules of civilization to them is beyond me. Of course they are going to trample what most people view as within the bounds of normal. They are not normal. They are power hungry crazies.
American media is not media any more. If they were, Trump wouldn't be where he is.
Can you give us guidance on vetted ways for Americans to show support for Zelensky/Ukraine?
There is a list of reputable places to donate just above these comments.
Just saw that - thanks!
I have never been ashamed to tell people that I am a citizen of the USA. I am now.
The "performance" today by Trump and Vance was beyond despicable.
Well stated, Prof. Snyder.
I was ashamed during Nixon and Reagan’s reigns. But this is beyond the pale
Thank you for discerning what just happened as I am so upset can hardly put it into words.
As for actions, we each must call our Senators, Democrat and Republican.
Tell Repubs it is TIME FOR THE ADULTS to enter the room.
The world is watching to see if each Senator is on the side of Putin or America.
Tell Dems to put PRESSURE on Repub Senators.
This is seriously dangerous for national security.
I'm thinking 25th Amendment but of course that would not succeed right now.
I have been glued to this story for the past two hours. I watched the entire thing; the first 40-45 minutes were pretty bland, comparatively speaking. I kept looking for the part where Trump threw Zelensky out, but apparently that happened after the cameras stopped rolling. What an absolute disgrace.
THANK YOU for this video, which I posted to Facebook. Your words were very welcome.
In addition to Trump/Vance's humiliation of American global statesmanship, the public facing meeting we saw was a clear and classic lesson in how our fragile, adolescent leader uses word. We know well his words are never aligned with explaining the "truth" or even an attempt to tell the truth. His words a usually lies when held up to reality. Trump only uses words to further his political agenda. In the case if Ukraine, his agenda is:
1. Publicly belittle Zelensky for Putin's entertainment.
2. Act like he's trying to be a fair and neutral negotiator for the purpose of saving Ukrainian lives. (This is particularly crazy considering the facts)
3. Look to the American public like he's just using "common sense" to settle a spat between two neighbors in a little local fight.
Why does the US need to carry this water?
4. Shift responsibility for giving up Ukraine to Putin by blaming Biden for the war.
5. Demonize Zelensky for not thankfully kowtowing to his eminence HRH Trump for all the support His Royalness has given him (this one is directed at his MAGA base)
Any reasonable person, living in the reality of Ukraine's current situation, know that everything Trump/Vance spewed at Zelensky was lies and propaganda. His purpose is to abandon Ukraine for Russia.
IMO, the reason is simple, Trump can grift much richer personal deals out of Putin than Zelensky.
Thanks so much for this insightful, quick response. I'm ashamed to be an American, today.
For those who understand German, I found this other quick response from Prof. Jaeger insightful: this was a manuscripted trap, arranged by Trump and Vance, for Zelensky: you can't make Americans like Putin, until you make them dislike Zelensky...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-eDejb4ha0
And do you think it will work? That what happened will make Americans hate Zelensky?
Democracy dies one bended knee to tyranny at a time. Today, Trump, Vance and Rubio bent the knee to Putin, spouting Russian talking points like robotic KGB operatives. Watching this indecent ambush of President Zelenskyy, a genuine hero for democracy, has sickened me.
And for what? Russia offers nothing of value - zilch - for American national or business interests. Our traditional allies in Europe and Canada offer exponentially more of value to our economy and national security. Trump’s personal grievances once again are at our nation’s and others’ expense.
Slava Ukraine!
Trump and Vance acted like the middle school bullies that they are devoid of empathy and dignity. Putin is clearly pulling the strings either having knowledge of something that Trump has done that would destroy his career or with the promise of riches in developing land in Russia, or both. Zelensky is more a leader and a dignified man than they will ever be.
Thank you Tim. Just made a donation. Was anyone else struck by the way Vance got Trump all riled up and entirely shifted the tone of the meeting? They are a disgrace.
Yes, well said, and I think Vance knew exactly what he was doing.
Dr. Snyder - is it too dangerous for you to give us your ideas on what trump is gaining from his deep, weird relationship with Putin? I think we have all guessed at possibilities like Putin has some kind of leverage on trump with secrets. But that no longer seems plausible because it seems like no information about how corrupt or indecent trump is has stopped his trajectory. Everyday, while being furious, I’m dumbfounded and mystified by what trump is gaining. For sure, we’re the biggest losers.
There have been recent articles quoting a former CIA Russian Specialist about Trump being recruited when he visited Russia in the 70's. T's code name Krasnov. How credible are these reports? What are the reasons T could have to cozy up to P now? We've heard T wants his legacy to be as a peacemaker - okay - but how does appeasing Russia serve that interest? As an historian, Prof Snyder, perhaps you can help us understand how we got to this point -- and how we can dial it back.
Prof. Snyder has already told us how we got to this point, nearly 7 years ago in "The Road to Unfreedom: Russia, Europe, America" (2018; updated Kindle ed. 2023). This little book is probably the best on the subject. When the first hardbound edition was published in 2018, he was way ahead of most scholars—so far ahead that many rejected its claims. Now it's considered to be the standard work on the subject. I've read it twice.
You don’t need an intelligence expert on this, just a decent journalist like Wayne Barrett or a columnist like Charles Pierce. The connections go back to his father, back to the 1940s and machine politics in NYC. He wasn’t recruited; he was born into it.
M Sellers Feb 23 on Substack - claims by KGB
https://open.substack.com/pub/michaeldsellers/p/a-deeper-look-at-claims-by-kgb-officer?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=13nvrr
See above my reply
I found it powerful and insightful. And i always prefer to read than to watch.
These two soulless bullies engaged in a shakedown. Roy Cohn is applauding from his perch in Hell.
As an American and a supporter of democracy and the rule of law, I share the shame uniformly expressed below. It was revolting. I wonder, though, whether President Zelensky didn't get a few tactical wins from this embarrassing display by Trump, Vance (and Rubio in his cowardly silence). I imagine being subjected to this display helps solidify support for Zelensky both at home and throughout the EU and other nations that understand the basics dynamics of the illegal Russian invasion. I makes any deal struck without Ukraine at the table even less tenable than it was before today's infantile outbursts. While Zelensky may not "hold any cards" (what disgraceful framing!), the idiots in the Oval may have inadvertently dealt him a few by further exposing the irrationality (and impetuousness) of the American "policy" and "posture." What constituencies eager for peace (or even a cease fire with inadequate security guarantees) would support the values expressed by the American principals today?
Trump exposed himself as Putin's a lackey. The movie-gangster's lieutenant, imitating the boss's bluster, unwittingly reveals that he survives only so long as he is useful the real boss. How long will Trump be useful to Putin? This is real life, not a wish-fulfillment entertainment.
Thank you for synthesizing your thoughts and observations so clearly for all of us, especially regarding the important reminders of how host nations should behave in terms of basic hospitality and diplomacy.
The Tr-mp Administration is in full Wag-The-DOGe mode now.
It's very clear, what has been done in Russia will be done in the US by the Trump administration. Don't you think?
they are trying
I donated another USD100 to UA24 today after seeing this disgrace.
Thank you for what you have said via video. When I knew this meeting was coming, I felt a great deal of concern for President Zelenskyy and Ukraine. The entire scene felt staged and meant to provide a bunch of video for right wing/fascist media to keep pushing the putin poison into the body politic. Imagine baiting President Zelenskyy about his choice of clothes? When this regime proves over and over just how illegitimate it is, the question becomes, how much longer must we put up with such idiocy and obvious intention to crash the power institutions so that the people will be forced to swallow whatever this crowd of oligarchs decides they want to do? Almost 40 days is enough for me to know exactly what this crowd is up to. I am sure that I am not a minority wondering how to rid ourselves of this crowd of traitors.
Overwhelmed by shock, outrage, and shame at Trump and Vance's loathsome bullying. Clearly they had planned beforehand to attack, insult, and shout down President Zelensky. Their vile behavior got them to the White House, so why stop now? They don't know the meaning of hospitality, democracy, etc. because they're sociopathic brutes. Especially when Putin is dangling some tasty little carrot...how many millions into their secret bank accounts? Thanks so much for your video -- your voice of sanity was much needed after the anguish of watching that performance. Yes, please do more videos.
Thank you for articulating so eloquently what we patriotic Americans are feeling in this moment: rage, sadness, and shame. How dare those two despicable individuals portray the American people in this way. Tim, thank you for your video and for posting the links to Ukrainian aid agencies. I will give the absolute most that I can and I will participate in events in my area (Asheville, NC) to protest this embarrassing administration.
This was a powerful analysis of a horrible meeting as well as where we find ourselves in the world right now. I would welcome more videos.
The mere sight of Trump's face and sound of his voice are enough to make me retch. A psychologically sick individual--make that a diagnosable psychopath--is the leader of the free world. I'm a Canadian, in solidarity with all Americans who value the principles of democracy. I'd love to see a repeat of the Dr. Martin Luther King "I Have A Dream" march across northern states where Canadians could join in. The free world needs to unite against Trump the tyrant. Count me in!
Timothy Snyder, please stay healthy. America and the world need your voice.
Ben Wittes, the editor of Brookings Lawfare, has an interesting solution to this very problem. Where anything Trump says in public is almost instantly available online - in text - knows where to go and just reads it. And that way doesn’t have to hear “his voice.”
I firmly believe trump vance and a large number of American politicians have been subverted and are Russian agents. Putin is a KGB spymaster and this plan has been in process since he first gained power.
The American people have been fed disinformation for years. Their education system has been eroded. The social media platforms are full of lies and half truths and skew thinking into bizarre and fantastical ways. News media being controlled by the few focuses opinion in ever narrower ways.
If you believe that the US will never be like Nazi Germany, or the USSR or Russia or China you are wrong. It is happening right now in front of your eyes.
Thanks Tim for exposing this in such an elegant and descriptive way This day will go down in history as a truly dark day for America not only domestically but globally
Today WE the People need to vow to hold these scumbags accountable economically with debt strikes and at the ballot box
Our hearts go out to our sisters and brothers in Ukraine Slava Ukraine!!!
I am not an American. I am Australian. Even so, I feel fury and sadness in the way Trump (Ihe does not deserve to be called president) has treated President Zelensky. That is not the way to treat the leader of another country, let alone a democracy. I sincerely hope that most Americans who voted for Trump do not share his views on Ukraine and the Ukrainian President. They should tell him so. Under Trump the USA has become subservient to Putin and Russia. America is no longer great and is no longer a democracy.
Last night, my wife and I went to a performance of Anne Frank. I have avoided the story most of my life; afraid to feel those feelings. The young daughter of a friend of ours was the understudy for the lead. It was the understudy performance so the opening for our friends. The kids were amazing. The production was almost unbearable. Unbearable in the way a tender heart is hard to manage. I'm a 67 years-old man and I cried until my eyes dried. I thought of Ukraine often during the performance. Normal, flawed people in horrendous psychological and physical conditions trying to stay human. And these monsters trying to destroy everything around them. The hardest thing about it was knowing the kids in the show on the stage in front of me, acting out the pain the evil in the world can spawn, may have to really live it.
trump's behavior doesn't make diplomatic sense because he's not a diplomat. He wants to be just like Putin. He wants the riches and power and fawning that dictators enjoy. trump couldn't care less about democracy. Nothing in his behavior history even remotely suggests that he is concerned about Americans' well-being. trump is going to strip America of its wealth, health and humanity if he has the time. We can't look at trump as though he's an American President when he's doing everything he can to take the country apart, and harm it's citizens to weaken us to the point that we can't rebel. The most astounding aspect of this is how obvious it is that he has been nothing short of a traitorous barbarian.
The Ukrainian people and its brave leader Zelensky were insulted beyond words today. So grateful for Prof Snyder's calm yet chilling words (and the information about how to help).
What will shake the House and Senate from their passivity -- will this shameful and dangerous episode do it? I for one will look to AOC, Whitehouse, Sanders, and anyone else who shows the courage to stand up to bullies.
Thank you for you sobering but truthful comments. I was ashamed when I saw that display.
By demonstrating to Europe, Canada, and Mexico that we are unreliable allies and trading partners, we are now weaker and less secure. I am rooting for them to stand up to Russia because apparently we won’t and can’t.
I just finished your piece and reading Tom Nichol’s piece in the Atlantic, while my grandson is sleeping. The whole afternoon has felt surreal and beyond unsettling. No explanations can make a dark day seem brighter. It’s is a very dark day for our country. Our President the mob boss, with Vance as his consigliere, shaking down a supposed ally. If this does not send a message to all of our allies, nothing will.
Thank you for the suggestions on giving. I can at least give money and did so to Razom for Ukraine.
Beautifully said with seething rage
Thank you for expressing what I'm feeling
Tim, I think this is excellent. Just one thing: I think you said there was nothing that had not been said before by Russia that we heard today, and I think that is not accurate because I think Vance actually admitted, surprisingly, that Russia invaded Ukraine and bears responsibility for doing so.. something to that effect. Thank you for your wonderful and courageous work.
Thank you as always Prof Snyder.
Donald unpresidented
I have spent the last twelve hours processing waves of both rage and revulsion whilst friends of mine in Kyiv and Kharkiv hide under yet another wave of russian drone attacks. Thank you as always Tim for your clear-eyed calm perceptions. As a Brit, it's obvious to me that Starmer got played last week and that it's part of the ongoing Trump-Putin project to peel the UK away from the EU - and must be resisted as such. I hope that this is finally the wake-up call that Europe needs to make it realise the US currently has nothing we can use or need and is too busy collapsing in on itself to be of any use in fighting russian tyranny.
Those beaming pictures of Starmer and Lammy look sickening this morning, don't they. I hope they can redeem themselves a little at tomorrow's meeting. Otherwise, we have the state visit of Trump to look forward to.
There is a new leader of the free world and his name is Volodymyr Zelensky. The others were Russian shills, how shameful for the United States of America!
Yes, seething with rage at the indecent behavior of Trump and Vance, who cornered the President of Ukraine, a country under siege, a country that is standing as the vanguard for all of Europe against the Soviet menace. I am the 80 year old daughter of Veteran of the Battle of the Bulge. A man who came back home with a Silver Star, a Bronze Star and four Purple Hearts. He fought to save Europe, the US and all democratic countries from the barbarism, greed and cruelty of fascist regimes. Now, his honor and that of his Band of Brothers (snd Sisters) is being betrayed by the Bullies in the White House, Trump, Musk and Vance. Their behavior makes me sad and ashamed to be an American.
I appreciate your dispassionate analysis. I am ashamed and outraged. My father killed other human beings in the Philippines for democracy; my uncle was wounded in Normandy in '44. This traitor today spit on their memory; he spit on America. We're 5 weeks in and he's destroyed our fathers' honor, Americans' lives and any hope of trust in America. He aligns with murderous Putin. The Republicans defending him are shameless, spineless cowards. Traitors, all.
Re: video. Yes, please do more.
Much gratitude for your work.
One of the worst days of American history, certainly in my time. I am ashamed to be American at this point. We now have a new world order, in which Europe is bypassed, NATO may be history, and America will now continue its decline under an incompetent administration. Not clear where Europe goes now. Trump wants half the Ukrainian wealth , and in return offers nothing. Zelensky's trip was wasted. Good first video, keep going.
Jack Luzkow
STATE DEPT IS PHONE NUMBER IS
1-888-407-4747. You can go directly to extension 8 to leave a message. You have about 15 seconds. So plan it. I asked if Rubio was an American or a Russian. "That's your choice, pal."
Slava Ukraini
I am so happy you posted this right away. I am besides myself I feel shame embarrassment fear so many things. Thank you for putting it into perspective. Keep doing this as much as you can. It truly helps.
Feeling angry after this lucid description and analysis. America and current Russia as allies (!!!) goes beyond I would have ever envisaged. Ukraine will have to take the humiliating meeing and move on, creating new facts.
Donated to RAZOM - thank you for what you do!
Tim,
You are more restrained and articulate in this moment of American debasement than I can possibly be. I am no longer surprised by Trump's thuggish behavior but right now I am stunned by the openness of his bullying as well as his wheedling behavior.
How like him to be the aggrieved one. What, Zelensky had not been grateful for American aid? How many times did was he openly grateful, traveling to Washington, appearing at international conferences, in part singing for his supper but also saying thank you for helping us stay alive.
The problem for Trump isn't that Zelensky hasn't been grateful; but that he is not submissive To Trump. Trump needs to own other men.
I can only do what I can to give to United 24 but I hope that enough of us give to the Ukrainians in different ways so that they might know that they have not been abandoned.
Thank you, Professor Snyder. Your clear and succinct summary of the failures of the US President and Vice President, and by them in our behalf, expressed eloquently the feeling all Americans should have after such an embarrassing public exchange with one of our respected allies, a nation that has endured unbelievable threats to its very existence at the hands of Russian aggression. Every American should feel shame and embarrassment over the performance of two people who should have the maturity and good judgement to enable a respectable performance of competent diplomacy. That is not what we observed today. It was painful to watch, no matter what would be one's political party affiliation. God help us if this is what we have ahead of us going forward.
I think ‘renaming the Gulf’ was a precursor to this ambush today. No one can tell me this wasn’t preplanned. They are signaling the dissolution of the United States of America. I operate from a stance of “failure to imagine” will be the contribution to our downfall. And failure to act (all Americans) is the nail in our 250 year history.
So T. just turned our country over to Putin.....and our Politicos are preoccupied with upcoming elections ....... as if the regime would let that happen. Call the Police.....of some nice country,
I am grateful that I did not watch Donald Trump because seeing him in person is not what I want. I would rather hear about it after the fact. Here is an analysis of the relationship between the US and Ukraine by Stephen Wertheim in discussion with Anand Giriharandas on his Substack. Would love your response to this.
https://open.substack.com/pub/anandwrites/p/live-america-and-the-world-with-stephen-wertheim?r=f0qfn&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=email
Another friend was discussing how China and and Russia are openly recruiting from our disgruntled Intelligence Community of fired employees.
https://edition.cnn.com/2025/02/28/politics/us-intel-russia-china-attempt-recruit-disgruntled-federal-employees/index.html
I have written my political party in Germany to say that Germany and EU countries that are NATO allies should be recruiting these people as consultants, and from our military too. Honestly, while I am an EU and US citizen I am on the side of democracy. Diminishing Trump and the MAGA/Heritage Foundation/Opus Dei/Federalist Society/Christian Nationalists power which Trump is doing in every step, does not necessarily give Putin the power he needs if Europe steps up. They have the money, but not the manpower. Both of those things can change even if not overnight. I am thinking about how much countries got off of Russian gas on a dime when they had to, and urgency could possibly bring about that can do spirit again.
That is what I get from Wertheim, which is that while we can acknowledge that it was not humane what Trump did, we do not expect that from Mr. Transactional anyway. I take comfort in seeing that Russia does not really have much to offer Trump and ultimately he might disappoint them again.
Thank you for sharing your wisdom and experience. What happened today was a disgrace.
Great work Dr. Snyder. Thank you. Our hearts are breaking tonight.
Thank you Tim.
Thank you for this analysis. It was such a shocking mess, I appreciate you breaking it down this way!
Thank you so so much for your incredible insight! This is, indeed, a very dark day. What happened to integrity??
There are a couple of troubling historical precedents for what Trump did to Zelensky today (Feb.28, 2025). As we know from Trump's Art-Of-the-Deal ghost writer, Donald has kept a copy of Mein Kampf on his night table. It may be one of the few books which he actually has read and from which his mind, such as it is, shows permanent signs of having digested. Almost exactly 87 years ago Hitler was busy planning how to enable the 3rd Reich to swallow Austria. He invited the Chancellor of Austria, to visit the Berghof where Hitler and his closest advisors and other criminals were at home for the moment. Chancellor Schnuschnigg paid Hitler the visit on Feb.12, 1938 with the hope, like that of Zelensky, of convincing the Führer to moderate his Nazi rhetorical lies and help instead to calm down the Nazi movement in Austria. Instead, Hitler brutally presented Schushnigg with a dead-set ultimatum which stipulated that Nazi, Seyss-Inquart, would become chief of the Austrian police force. In addition, all imprisoned Nazis were to be released. Hitler was sadistically abusive to the Austrian Chancellor who was forced to sign the ultimatum before leaving Bergtesgaden. Some weeks after returning home Schnussnigg announced that a plebiscite would be held in mid-March. Hitler demanded Schuschnigg's resignation and the appointment of Seyss-Inquart as Chancellor. This second ultimatum, like the previous one, forced obedience from Schuschnigg. On March 12, Schuschnigg was put under house arrest. Does this sound familiar with reference to Zelinsky and where things are heading for him? Unlike Schuschnigg, Zelinsky refused to sign Trump's ultimatum. It now looks as if, in their phone conversations, Trump and Putin agreed on how they intend to divide Ukraine between the two of them: the USA will receive total rights over the rich minerals and other valuable Ukrainian assets; Putin will receive the whole real estate of the country right up to its pre-war borders. The precedents for this "solution" would be the Anschluss of 1938 and the Stalin-Hitler shared land-grab of Poland in 1939. After today's staged, loud-mouthed ultimatum-show, Trump and Vance will be only too happy if Zelensky can be subjected to house arrest and then handed over to Putin for a long stay in the Gulag or an accident because someone left a Kremlin window open or simply, the Pregoshin finale. Putin aims to create a 4th Reich with addition of Ukraine, Moravia, Lithuania, Estonia, Finland and whatever else is up for grabs. Trump and his boss, Musk, will be happy to transform the USA into a 5th Reich or a 6th Reich, with the inclusion of Canada's 10 provinces, Panama, Mexico, Greenland, Denmark and Finland. Possibly, Trudeau and Zelinsky might even run into each other after Siberia and recall the old days before Donald kicked the (frozen) bucket and Vance sought exile in India.
An astute observation. Thank you for bringing up that chilling piece of history. I have visions of Trump ending up like Mussolini.
Or: Bone-Spur Donnie given last rites Quadaffi-style.
Oh joy! A rat in a hole.
I suggested the following to Senator Schumer (one of my senators) and a similar one to my NY Representative. I would love to hear people’s thoughts about it!
Senator Schumer,
With our federal laws and even our Constitution being violated by a rogue President, now is the time for you and your fellow Democrats and Independents (and any Republicans who have the courage) to lead in the resistance. We need a strong statement, one that is symbolic, impactful, AND feasible.
So here is my suggestion: a Liberty Torch relay to Washington, D.C. that passes through villages, towns, cities, and suburbs on its way to D.C. via state capitals, with perhaps a scheduled "arrival" in D.C. on July 4th. There would be a statement on the torch reaffirming commitment to uphold and protect the Constitution of the United States, and then there would be a digital mechanism, perhaps using blockchain technology, for Americans to electronically sign their name to that statement. This would enable Americans to sign onto the statement without having to physically attend the relay. And the torch would be not one torch but 435 torches that start in the Congressional districts and make their way to their state capital. If blockchain is used, then with each signature, the blockchain gets longer. As these torches are relayed there would be opportunities for ceremonies to receive and pass on the torch, with marches and caravans along the way.
From each state capital, a caravan of that state's torches would then drive to Washington D.C. An "app" could be set up to enable Americans to track the relay of the torches along with signatures as they came in. PSAs and local and national media would track the spectacle. There would then be a grand Constitutional lighting ceremony in Washington D.C. attended by Congressional and civil leaders to receive the 435 torches where they would be displayed. Each Senator and House Representative, Supreme Court Justice, and the President would then be called on to reaffirm their commitment, per their oath of office, to support and defend the Constitution of the United States by signing a federal version of the torch.
A nonresponse to these historically unprecedented attacks on our Constitution and underlying democratic norms would reinforce these attacks by implicitly accepting them. Our hand is forced. The time for action--to say that this in not normal or acceptable--is now.
Please let me know what you think. I stand ready to help make something like this happen.
Thank you,
Stephan Brown
I am not an American and have been upset by the people from POTUS to unelected people such as Musk running the US with ignorance, and bullying. I have felt only the American people can rise up and object to their leader’s ignorance and contempt for others, and even their dismissal of the rules of law. Your comments, Mr Snyder, and those who have commented here gives a ray of hope that Americans still care for democratic values despite the mores of the people who are in charge. Continue to express your dismay. The rest of the world needs to know there are American citizens that care for decency and respect. It gives us hope
The anger that I feel having those horrible people—truly “man-children”- in the Oval Office treat Zelenskyy the way they did is beyond outrage. Every American who voted for Trump and his thugs can now have that meeting, which will be broadcast all over the world, on their consciences—it was the most egregious display of just plain craziness, stupidity, egomania and treason as far as I am concerned. Shame on the White House leadership. Zelensky I am sure is smart enough to know that there are still many good and supportive Americans in his corner, but that others here unfortunately have been hoodwinked by the conmen of this nation.
A disgraceful day for the United States. As an Australian I wish our government would cancel the submarine deal with the US. You cannot trust the US anymore. Surely Trump is a Russian operative? How else do you account for his insane behaviour. I stand with Ukraine and hope Europe and Australia commit more rigorously to defending their independence.
Just despicable behavior, these two man child’s have absolutely no idea what the Ukrainians have endured. God help us because these fools in the Whitehouse are clueless…and Lindsey Graham just posted the most obscene support for what just happened. Hard to be rational with this kind of behavior….and the comment about not wearing a suite. OMG. What is it going to take to stop this madness.
I became a paid subscriber today and gave to the Come Back Alive charity recommended above. I am horrified, disgusted, and embarrassed. But maybe it's somehow better that the world saw exactly where Trump and his sidekick jd stand. Whatever they will do now is probably what they were planning to do anyway.
I donated again today. Your clarity is outstanding. I echo what Ron Filipkowski/Meidas said on Bluesky today - "I despise this orange scumbag with the intensity of 1000 suns". I might have made it 1 million. Written or video- keep on posting please. We need your voice more every day. Victory to Ukraine!
Typically good assessment by Snyder. I hope he'll do more of these.
There was a bitter online response...the world is really turning against Trump...
https://barrygander.substack.com/p/trump-and-vance-gang-up-on-zelensky
“What we witnessed today all too clearly was the beginning of an American alliance with Russia” Thank you, Professor Snyder for your clarity.
The tag line on this post should read "Trump aided by his cast of thugs and grifters hurt America and Ukraine badly today."
Thank you for posting the ways to donate to help the brave Ukrainian people.
Thank you for doing this video. Please do more.
Here's the good news: As the video of the White House debacle goes viral world-wide, all Americans should be mortified by the churlish and unpardonable behavior of our purported leaders. Just as Zelensky is responsible for representing the Ukrainian people, Trump/Vance are responsible for representing us. What they did in our name today proves beyond a doubt that they are unequal to that responsibility.
Let nothing like this be done in our name again.
Thank you! Very well measured response, needed as one is all confused about the bizare ways of your new administration!
I think that today the US is no longer the leader of the free world and our magnificent democracy is hanging by a thread. I wish I could rush off to DC and protest in Lafayette Park in front of the White House on Monday but I can't. I wonder if we need to mourn in some visible way immediately - candles in the windows at night? A torch relay is a great idea but will we still be viable in July?
At least now we can all see that our deepest fears about this administration are accurate, and we need to show the world that this is our country and we are not handing it over to Russia and our citizens will not tolerate the abandonment of Ukraine. The disconnect between the warm breakfast reception for Zelenskyy with Congress and the gangster shakedown screaming in the Oval Office is astonishing. I kept expecting Musk and X to pop out of the fireplace to assist in the ambush.
Hoping the Democrats can come up with some silent reaction to Trump's lies in his address to the Joint Session on Tuesday - maybe covering their ears for every lie, as in Hear No Evil. It would cause a stir and make everyone look at them but not be any kind of interruption.
Thank you expressing what so many of us are feeling about the disgraceful, horrifying display of abysmal ignorance by Trump and Vance today. The President sneered that President Zelensky doesn't "hold the cards." Trump doesn't realize that HE is just one more card in Putin's hand... and he isn't an Ace or a King.
I'm weeping and seething, ashamed of my bullying USA leaders. Mr. Zelensky deserves the most grace and kindness, as does his country, his people, and as does the need for democratic values in the world.
I thank you so much, Timothy Snyder, for speaking out about these egregious actions.
Superb and powerful summation. Thank you. Please continue the videos when you are able.
So now let's redouble our efforts: calls, office visits to our Reps, emails, social media posts, donations, protests, boycotts. We need everyone who cares about our country, and Ukraine, to stand up, get tough(er), use any and all means we can to resist.
Thank you, Professor Snyder, for your prompt and eloquent response. I think we are all so shocked that it’s hard to formulate a response in words. But, despite your own obvious distress, you’ve managed to do that and, even more importantly, to provide us with a framework within which we can begin to structure our own.
So embarrassing for our country. No decency. No honor. Just 2 little boys who can’t think for themselves and have no integrity.
What an incredibly sad and embarrassing day for our country. It was appalling. That was not who we are. To watch our so-called 'leaders' show no decency, no understanding, no empathy is outrageous. They need to be shown the door.
Professor Snyder is on Deadline Whitehouse, msnbc 5:45 pm 2/28
Thank you, this was spot on.
The violations of decency, respect for what Ukraine and Zelensky have been through were astounding. Violation of 80years of dependable alliances for nothing. I'm going to up my donations to Ukraine and I hope millions of other decent Americans will too.
Thank you - please keep talking to us. America needs to do SO much better than what was on display in the oval office today. Having you address the dreadful behavior of today helps me distill how to discuss Ukraine with my right wing friends/colleagues who get their news from right wing silos. I stand with Ukraine - thank you for adding so eloquently to the verbiage around why everyone in America still should.
Thank you for voicing these points. I watched those scenes in the Oval Office today with dismay wondering how to counter them. Your links to agencies that support Ukraine are most appreciated and the response I’ve made this evening is to DONATE. Renewed thanks for your wise words.
I'm starting to believe the last election WAS stolen- there couldn't possibly be that many ignorant or stupid people who voted for this incredibly rude, disgraceful convicted felon now leading the U.S. down a path of destruction. I am so horrified. I do appreciate the video & links to help Ukraine.
Thank you for the links. I donated to RAZOM. Super fast and easy.
Thank You Dr. Snyder.
This really helped the squash sized knot that I had in gut after watching the
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy ambush in our White House.
I am 88, Mrs. B is 94 we needed to hear this.
Thank You for allowing us to share this.
Mr. B.
A Heartfelt Request to Continue Your Vital Work
Dear Professor Snyder,
I’m writing to express my deepest gratitude for your work—and to humbly ask that you continue creating videos whenever possible. Your articles and insights have been a lifeline for me during these disorienting months, offering clarity and moral grounding as I grapple with the grief of witnessing antidemocratic forces erode the country I love. Your voice cuts through the noise, reminding me what we’re fighting for, not just against.
My uncle, a medic, in World War II, risked his life to save soldiers on battlefields where fascism seemed unstoppable. He survived, built a family, and taught me that democracy isn’t a given—it’s something we choose, daily, through courage and vigilance. Your work feels like an extension of that same fight. When I watch your videos, I don’t just hear analysis; I’m reminded of the values he embodied—the ones that still make this country worth saving.
Please know how much your perspective matters, especially now. For those of us who care about freedom and human decency, your words are a compass. If you’re able, I hope you’ll keep sharing your voice through videos. They don’t just inform—they fortify.
With immense respect and gratitude,
Lydia Craigmyle
I very much like this video. Although I feel so much fury I feel like I am walking around in a constant state of tight self restraint, I find the bland, almost emotionless delivery registers with me as restraint and not a lack of emotional investment. I believe the word choice is careful and each term invested with more meaning than in the expulsive slandering we witnessed in the White House from "our leaders". If you can do more videos, please do.
As a paid reader, I do not know if this article is viewable by all but I hope so as I intend to share the link widely with the suggestion that with this regime's surrender of honor, private American citizens should (where they can) contribute to support Ukraine.
Things that give me cheer. Remembering the last days of Mussolini and the certainty that the Trump name will be etched in history along with Hitler, Himmler, Goring and Goebbels.
Thank you for this! Friday was a difficult day for many Americans who love America and who support Ukraine. 🇺🇦
I sent this to my representatives:
I’m writing in hope that you come out with a strong condemnation of what the so-called U.S. president and vice (emphasis on vice) president’s obvious ambush of Mr. Zelenskyy yesterday. If it was ever in doubt, there is doubt no longer that this administration is in league with Putin and all the atrocities associated with him.
Thank you
Thank you for putting in words what I still struggle to process…. Your video indeed was helpful as it prompted me into “action” and got me out of the numbness I felt after witnessing the horror show in the office of the US President; I just donated to one of the organizations you listed below — thank you for providing the links; I also just ordered a Ukrainian flag to display in a visible place of my home in support of Ukraine although the bylaws of our condo association do not permit such displays ( in desperate times some principles fly out the window….) than you again !!
My friend Yuliya Makliuk, Ukrainian potter and ecologist, says It's OK to be shocked for a while - it's what you do afterwards that matters. She sells her work to benefit the war effort, and also gives free art therapy classes for wounded veterans. That's what she is doing this morning in her studio in Irpin. I get a lot of strength from her.
Deeply depressed thanks, Timothy, for again clearly formulating the indecency, the irrationality, and the un-American behavior demonstrated by the US WH “Hosts” yesterday. Merely witnessed by the civilized, the entire world.
Thank you for the video. I think your compassion and thoughtful analysis are very clear. The display in the Oval Office today was that of a overinflated defense attorney desperately trying to convince the jurors that his client is not a demented murderer who has lost contact with reality while gaslighting the one man of honour in the discussion.
I can't begin to describe the fury I feel at this utter betrayal of the American values, however imperfect, that I've lived and believed in for 82 years. In my town there will be a rally in support of Zelenskyy and Ukraine this weekend. I hope to see these rallies all over the country. This is not us!
You are a shining light in a sombre world seen this morning from Denmark.
Apparently Trump and the Republicans see no harm in Russia proceeding to take over Ukraine, its land, people, army and weapons capacities. The question remains - why ?
A relevant parallel is Hitler. In 1938, the UK tried and failed to appease Hitler. However, few actually supported him in the way that the US is now supporting the barbaric Putin and effectively saying, let him take what he wants before thousands are sent to Siberian prison camps while millions flee.
i am so ashamed!
Both my parents fought for 6 years against fascism in Europe. My father was in a unit that relieved Bergen Belsen. I visited the camp with him years later. I have his letters and photos sent from there. Trump couldn't even get the year of Russia's invasion right. We will stand with Ukraine to resist Russia. Where are you America?
Thank you for your analysis and support in this dark time in American and Western history. My heart breaks for Pres. Zelenskyy and the Ukrainian people. Utter disgrace by so-called American leaders.
Thank you, Prof Snyder, for these candid words.
Please, please, please let Pres Zelenskyy know that many of us, out of enduring respect and human caring, will stand with Ukraine, will support the Ukrainian people in their self-defense.
We will work with them all the way. They are committed to success, to fully achieving a just and durable victory and a just and durable postwar of international cooperation and mutual international enforceable security.
Trump and JD Vance deserve only full contempt from us; I promised them [via the contact the White House] that I will stand with Ukraine.
This is such an impressive, humane and ethical profound analysis, Timothy!
You are so right about hospitality as the first most basic thing. I felt the same. How can you treat a guest like this? Who would ask the guest who traveled from a war torn country why he would not wear a suit?
It is clear that Trump is a Russian pawn. Whether it is the typical authoritarian fascination with power or threats and compromat on his head, Trump is acting like Putin’s puppet.
IMO Trump committed treason today, and by selling US and our allies down the river.
As outraged and disgusted as I am, I’m not surprised. I still remember the infamous 2018 Helsinki press conference when Trump, looking like a hanged dog, told the world he thought Putin’s word carried more weight than the US intelligence services.
I’m going to write to my representatives to ask that this traitor be impeached.
All five points are correct. I found it particularly poignant the comments on hospitality and decency.
As someone who is deeply interested in the history and fate of Europe particularly Eastern Europe this is a very dark day. America has crossed into the Putin camp - for what reason I don't know, for what gain I don't know.
Maybe ordinary Americans will make a stand on this betrayal not only of Ukraine but its Allies.
My beloved wife, a Pole, was always sceptical, about US support. While she would feel vindicated she would be saddened. The fall of the Soviet Union was a great day. Now Trump is opening the doors for Russia again.
Whatever happens it will be hard to trust the USA again, even if Trump goes in 4 years.
Robert Estrada
I served in the US Infantry in our part of NATO for about 2 years. There is NO ethical or moral difference between the USSR and what we face now. I wish we Americans had leader of the caliber and quality of Volodymyr Zelensky. I stand in awe of that man. A man who’s stature exceeds all but the best of our leaders , whom he equals.
Prof. Snyder asks for feedback at the end of his address regarding the Oval Office Mugging. Should he continue holding these video events? YES, Timothy.
I am sharing widely. Thank you.
Professor Snyder, you have the picture right. I felt the same shame and disgust you expressed.
I'm giving to one of the funds you suggested. And I'm forwarding your message to my regional newspaper, read in rural northwest Ohio, where the large majority of people customarily vote for people in the party of the current president. As a person of faith, I'm also praying for victory for Ukraine and peace as soon as possible.
where can we write to Zelinsky to express our deep embarrassment and apologies
I wonder if Zelenskyy truly believed that Trump would offer something positive in this meeting. My gut says he didn't but he had to make the effort.
As an Australian, I am shocked by the narcissistic tirade I witnessed by 47 and JDV. Gaslighting has now reached a whole new height of insanity. I have made a donation to United 24 and will encourage all in my circles to do likewise.
My husband and I donated again to RAZOM. This time, in comments, we thanked President Zelensky. What a brave man. He followed the ambush in the Oval Office with keeping his promise of an interview on Fox. He did a fine job of defending his people and making sure we understood he represents them and isn’t in this position for himself (unlike Trump).
Your video on this shocking occasion is just brilliant and so very powerful. Your sanity and calm come through with such clarity and strength. I have learned so much from your excellent writings, but hope you also have the time and space for more videos when you are so inspired to share them. Thank you for all the work you do. Voices like yours are invaluable during these gut wrenching times.
Gangster movies is a major genre in Hong Kong cinema. So I watched those movies growing up. There is a “formula” in terms of how to portray the gangster boss and his subordinates. Today, when I watched the tape, this scene came to mind. JD Vance is like the subordinate who kicked the guy who dare to “talk back” to his boss. In the movie, this subordinate will beat up the guy. It felt this way today. Two bigger louder “Americans” yelling at a small guy who struggled to defend himself and in this case, the dignity of his country, which is in war, using a second language. Do you think anyone who has an ounce of decency will be OK with it? China does not need to make any propaganda film to tell the world about ugly Americans. We just showed the whole world. I almost throw up.
Today the Mump Regime showed me something about myself. I didn't know I could experience this level of rage and embarrassment. I very much appreciate that you published this video so soon after the horrific display today. As soon as I regained my ability to think I wondered what you would say. I recalled that you predicted chaos. I remembered your admonition to stay calm when the unthinkable happens. I feel my country has been taken hostage...that I have been taken hostage. I share Adam Kinzinger's feeling that, "I might explode." Your calm yet thunderous words help me. Thank you.
Thank you, Prof. Synder. Today, America officially became subservient to Russia. This has been Putin's "wet dream" for decades. History will show that when Trump visited Moscow in 1987, it set off a chain reaction of events that led to the most successful "invasion" in the history of modern, global warfare. Russia invested very wisely in cultivating an alliance with this psychologically weak, man-baby. And American journalism and law enforcement let is proceed unchecked by either public outrage or legally available remedies. I offer the disgusting response by Preet Bharara to the question "Why didn't you ever arrest Trump?" as just one fork-in-the-road moment in the history of that invasion for all to see...
God help us all, and Slava Ukraini...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUEOSgkQ4As
As an American I am deeply ashamed by the scene at the White House this afternoon - a disgrace. It does make me want to cry. Thank you Timothy Snyder for your profound eloquence and truth telling.
Trump/Vance were there to please one audience: the war criminal Putin ONLY. I understand that Russian TV or reporters were inside the Oval. What a disgrace of this country!!
Trump IS a Russian asset. That is pretty much the only explanation. This is old news in Europe, by the way. I am sick.
Thanks Dr. Snyder. What a disgusting display of disrespect and hubris. I'm so ashamed of the president and vice president.
Thank you, Dr. Snyder for providing an analytical framework to consider the unthinkable with dignity. Personally, I saw only one image on the front page of the Chicago Tribune’s evening edition. The body language of the three men said everything I needed to know. Our president and vice president thought they were trying to convince a sullen child. Zelensky, the young world leader, was dignified, resolute and determined, and will not ever be swayed by their ridiculous antics. Nothing can compare to the losses Ukraine has suffered, but the effects of today will cost Americans a lot of money, and likely the lives of a lot of our soldiers as Trump, Vance and Hegseth rapidly march us into World War 3.
Dr. Snyder, thank you for sharing your knowledgeable perspectives today. You give democracy a voice with important insights that very few can rival.
Professor Snyder: Thank you very much for your video which so clearly describes the failings Trump and Vance exhibited at their outrageous Oval Office meeting with President Zelensky today. They have the negotiating "chops" of a stupid Attila the Hun.
Beautifully done, Prof. Snyder: succinct, haunting, yet lyrical. Please give us more videos.
I watched the entire presser. The Putin talking points were bad enough. When these useful idiots started blaming, raising their voices like little kids, and demanding thanks, they actually managed to surprise me once again.
Not that I expect better of them, but outright hostility in public did manage to surprise.
Deeply appreciate you and your video. And I agree with all 5.
Thumbs up. Thank you!!!
My hero. Ty.
Appreciate your seriousness & your ability to zero in the truth and explain it for us all. You are a guide, & I’m very grateful for this.
Thank you so much, and YES! Please do more videos (as well as writing)! Your clear, wise voice is helping us immensely, as we live through this time, fighting for our democracy. You are a blessing! 💙 🇺🇦
Do more. Trump & Vance should be BOTH be IMPEACHED for TREASON (aiding and abetting our enemy - Russia) and reneging on the signed Budapest Memorandum of 1994. Call all the House Representatives:
Call: (202) 225-3121
We signed a commitment.- the “Budapest Memorandum” along with the UK, Northern Ireland and Russia! In 1994 Ukraine handed over nuclear weapons to Russia 'in exchange for a guarantee never to be threatened or invaded.'
Russia did NOT keep the commitment but the United States must. Perhaps Trump, being the non reader, poor student he was, doesn’t know about this commitment.
“This Memorandum will become applicable upon signature. Signed in four copies having equal validity in the Ukrainian, English, and Russian languages.” https://en.m.wikisource.org/wiki/Ukraine._Memorandum_on_Security_Assurances
They both should be impeached for Treason. They are both Russian assets, it’s obvious
Great video. Thank you. Failures: Hospitality, Decency, Democracy, Strategy, Lack of Independence. As you talked about failure of strategy a thought came to me of conscription of Americans to fight Russian wars. Failure of independence of giving over all our technology to this end. By God, this regime and its sycophants must go now.
Thank you for the donation links and for your substack. Robert Hubbell referred me.
Yes to the videos and thanks for the links.
Thank you, Dr. Snyder. Like millions of others, I am wounded beyond words. The suffering, death, destruction, and decay these awful people- T and V and their agents- are causing abroad and at home is unfathomable. As a grandmother, my great personal pain is knowing my teenage grandchildren are coming of age with this growing wreckage around them.
Your response was an excellent, well thought out response and one I definitely share with you. As always I agree strongly with your opinions and your books! Thank you and please issue more videos.
Yes, please record videos as you are able and written posts. All of your thoughts are precious and helpful to me.
Thank you for sharing your thoughtful and informed summary of today's disaster. I am embarassed to be an American today. Americans who love our country must unite and resist the current president of the US.
I am just so frustrated with what I watched in the White House. I am a Veteran (USAF) and now wonder if it is time to consider finding a new country to live in. I no longer recognize this country. How did we get here and how can we save our country.
I am so appreciative of your wise and thoughtful words. I wish that all Americans could - would - hear this and think about the points that you make so clearly and succinctly. Thank you for being such a wise voice in this perilous time. Please continue with videos, which are so easy to forward to others.
My dad was in WWll with Patton's 6th Armored Division. He joined them in September after DDay. He was at the Battle of the Bulge. They were the first of the US Army at Buchenwald which had been "liberated" the previous day when the guards ran away leaving the gates open. He would be ashamed of what has become of the Republican party he belonged to his whole life. The life he risked to defeat fascism and dictatorship. He would be appalled at the juvenile delinquent behavior of the US president and vice-president. As a US citizen I apologize to the world for our slide into barbarism. We were better than these bullies and we WILL get back there. Ee screw up big-time. Slava Ukraini
I am so grateful for your clear headed and brave comments on democracy, authoritarianism, and Ukraine. We've bought and gifted your books. As a an emeritus law prof. I am so proud of you.
Thank you so very much for this measured, truthful response. You are naming the truth with discipline, courage and power.
Thank you, Tim - I have been reading your posts on Substack.
It was nice to see you present them.
I agree with Sarah Swenson‘s comment above
Dear Mr. Snyder,
Thank you for your first substack video and the five failures explanation. Should you be able to read this, please consider reviewing the virtues and accomplishments of an organization called BlueCheck Ukraine https://www.bluecheck.in You may already be aware of this organization. May I suggest that you, once you've applied your vetting process, to add this organization to your list of places where one can donate/support Ukrainian people. Should you wish to interact with any, [and haven't done this already], please reach out to Murphy Poindexter for any appointments to discuss BlueCheck Ukraine's mission, 2024 reports and its current initiative to reach a goal of 2 million US$ towards local humanitarian aid with vetted on-the-ground organizations who are supplying and delivering medicines to elderly, wounded, oncology treatment for children... Thank you for considering the above. Julia Miller, Staten Island, NY
Your written words are always powerful, Prof Snyder, delivered in video they are even more so. Thank you.
I’m positive that Trumpf is no student of history so he may not be chastened by Mussolini’s death ( practically his doppelgänger). The most delicious, at this point that we can hope for is, unless there is a military coup, is that he will eat himself to death like King Farouk.
This video is deeply moving. Thank you.
This is very, very difficult, and sad day for America. I appreciated your video with concise information, and would watch if you did more. We stood at a busy intersection in my town at rush hour with the Ukrainian flag , and many signs.
There are many folks of Ukranian descent in this area, as well as Ukranians who moved here after the war started, and are very worried.
Please continue to share videos. Your books are helping me and those I love very much.
Facebook asks "What's on your mind?"
What's on my mind? Timothy Snyder nails it.
Gangster movies are a major genre in Hong Kong cinema. So I watched those movies growing up. There is a “formula” in terms of how to portray the gangster boss and his subordinates. Today, when I watched the tape, this scene came to mind. JD Vance is like the subordinate who kicked the guy who dared to “talk back” to his boss. Even the line uttered “You disrespect our boss” was the same. In the movie, this subordinate will then slap and beat up the guy. It felt this way today. Two bigger, louder “Americans” yelling at a smaller guy who struggled to defend himself and in this case, the dignity of his country, which is in war, hindered by the usage of a language not his own. Do you think anyone with an ounce of decency will be OK with it? China does not need to make any propaganda film to tell the world about ugly Americans. We just showed the whole world. I almost threw up.
Thank you for this very sobering and tragic update. I'm very grateful for your work and commitment to truth and freedom.
Prof everywhere 2/28 All In 8:30 pm msnbc. !!!! This is a wonderful interview and discussion with David Remnick and Chris Hayes
Trump/Vance behavior and rhetoric was shocking. Not only to me, but to the world. This betrayal recalls Hitler’s attack against his erstwhile ally, Russia, early in WW2. We have forsaken Ukraine and the EU.This cannot stand. The US Government must be SHUT DOWN BY CONGRESS.
Thank you, Prof Snyder, for your insight, inteligence, and steadfastness. Thank you for laying it all out
Please send out the list of Ukrainian causes, including military and trauma etc, thank you
At the end of his speech there is a list.
The video is good. After a long day of reading texts, etc., getting a calm, direct, and factual account of the Trump regime going after Zelensky helped. I have not yet had the strength to watch the wanna-be-king be rude, because it is a beautiful, early spring day here in California and I need to soak up that strength before I watch this dispicable, dublitious, lying buddy of Putin spit in the face of one of my heroes and a cause I support. I will happily donate to one of the programs you have linked. Thank you for all you do. This is painful in the extreme, but that pain is strengthening our resolve to fight back.
Excellent job on the pbs NewsHour tonight, Dr Snyder!
I REFUSE to let this abomination of an administration assert they speak for America. As far as I'm concerned, they and their GOP lackeys are traitors, for they violate their oaths of office every time they open their mouths.
I too am seething with rage and trying to stave off the worst emotion for me, which is shame. I am probably the only first generation person still alive, whose mother was one of the 332 women veterans of World War One. I wrote the first book on these Women and the Great War in 1976, when I was an Asst Prof at the Hutchins School of Liberal Studies, Calif State Univ Sonoma. Congress apparently just bestowed on them a gold medal, after denying they were veterans until 1978. I'd like to send it back saying these women would have all felt as I do today about the US president and would'vw revered the Ukrainian president. I am sending money to Ukraine and thank Prof Snyder for making it possible to do so directly.
Thank you for this summary of what we witnessed today. It was a clear alignment with Russia. History will remember this moment and it will not be kind.