Thinking about...

Comments on this post are for paid subscribers

491 Comments
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (5)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenAnti-RepubliCON Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 11
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 11
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenNonviolent Testosterone Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenWhat’s The Point Feb 11
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenNonviolent Testosterone Feb 11
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenGMan’s Musings On History and P… Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenThe Similitude Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (6)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (4)
Share
hiddenThe Similitude Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenThe Similitude Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (9)
Share
hiddenAlexandra’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenDonna’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenBruce’s Newsletter Feb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
founding
hiddenDeborah’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenAnti-RepubliCON Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenSPW Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenAnti-RepubliCON Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenDeborah’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenBabette’s Newsletter Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenDeborah’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (4)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenAnti-RepubliCON Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenAnti-RepubliCON Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenAnti-RepubliCON Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenVicki’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenAlexandra’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenMarg’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenMary’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenStephen’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenStephen’s Substack Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFred’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenMary’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenshannon’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenshannon’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenshannon’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenshannon’s Substack Feb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenshannon’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenshannon’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (4)
Share
hiddenPotter Feb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenVicki’s Substack Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenirene’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenirene’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenirene’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenKen’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenBryan’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenOpening Our Eyes Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (4)
Share
hiddenOpening Our Eyes Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenThoughts from the edge Feb 13
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenAlexandra’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenVirginia’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenRosanne’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenRosanne’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenRosanne’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (4)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenGreg’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 10
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFred’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 15
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenteresafbrooks’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 15
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenMarlene’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 12
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenMarlene’s Substack Feb 12
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 11
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 11
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenBruce’s Newsletter Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenJohn’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (5)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenRosanne’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenRosanne’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenBette Dangerous Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenfreddy’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9·edited Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenTony’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenThe Trident Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (4)
Share
author
Timothy Snyder
Feb 9Author
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (1)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (3)
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
hiddenFeb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply
Share
founding
hiddenVicki’s Substack Feb 9
Comment hidden
Expand full comment
Reply (2)