59 Comments

Eyebrows were raised when FDR and Churchill, in 1943, announced that WW II could only be concluded with ‘unconditional surrender.’

I sense the same concern, when President Zelensky refuses to commit to any ‘peace’ that includes continued occupation of Ukrainian soil, including Crimea.

Whatever the ruminations about humiliating Putin after his brutal invasion of sovereign Ukraine, personally I like the timbre of ‘unconditional surrender.’

Expand full comment

Dr. Snyder, I'm sure you saw the open letter in the NYT today calling for a swift diplomatic end to the war. <insert eyeroll emoji> Perhaps you could do a future piece on how well-intended, useful idiots help Russia's cause....

Expand full comment
founding

It's so good Dr.Snyder demonstrates how to counter Russian propaganda. People need more understanding of how to disregard and make sense of Russian propaganda twists and spins and fogs.

Expand full comment

A Norwegian guy woke Russian diplomats in Oslo after 2 am with an air raid siren on the anniversary of the invasion of Ukraine. 🚨 📢

May the guilty war criminals pay! #ICC

Expand full comment

Why I think about Ukraine every day. And some nights, too.

Expand full comment

Good analogy on US and Canada!

Expand full comment

Tim, it is not just terrorism and a war crime to explicitly target non-combatants, but it is also plainly stupid military strategy. It shows the inherent weakness behind the bullying and bluster of Russia. They cannot attack AFU, they already know how that goes. So they attack civilians instead. And now Russia knows it can no longer do that successfully. Hence the ramp of propaganda and disinformation.

Expand full comment

Thank you Dr. Snyder for once again making it very clear what Russia and its propagandists are all about. In a world full of nonsense, you are the voice that makes sense.

Expand full comment

I sure hope someone in the White House is on this distro, because Prof. Snyder is absolutely spot on. Ukrainian victory, not simply some sort of ceasefire, is the best way to ensure European and U.S. security. Anything less, and we're doing this again in 2026.

Expand full comment
May 17, 2023·edited May 17, 2023

Good column. Fascism in whatever form, whether military attacks like Russia on Ukraine, or autocratic legislation like in Florida, banning books, school curricula, property ownership by certain foreign nationals, etc., must be met with swift and forceful resistance. It can never be permitted to gain complete control of a government or society, even though it has in the past, and we have seen how that went. In the US, massive voter turnout is needed to counteract the creeping fascism in many state governments and in national political candidates. In Europe, massive military support for Ukraine is needed to counteract the actual fascism of war that Russia has unleashed on Ukraine, along with terrorizing civilians. There is no other way.

Expand full comment

At a Senate hearing Secy. Blinken just said something like “never say never” to a question about defining Russia as a state sponsor of terrorism. Doing this would complicate things but maybe it is time. Also, time to give Kyiv the air power to defend its airspace and pursue a counteroffensive with adequate air cover and close in air support.

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing this, Dr. Snyder! And thank goodness for the self-defense systems in place in Ukraine!

I appreciate the analogy you used. I think that is a way to help bring the scenario to light for a lot of people that don't quite understand just how aggressive and outrageous Putin's actions are in this situation. This war needs to end with Russia's completely leaving Ukrainian territory -- all of it.

I am lucky. The distress of hearing missiles throughout the night is not something I've had to experience. My heart, and my actions, are with all Ukraine.

Expand full comment

This is the best piece by Dr. Snyder I have read (although I am far from being a completist). It succinctly and eloquently describes not only Putin’s strategy, but how to counter it, while including the very real impact decisions in Moscow have on the people of Ukraine.

Expand full comment

Keep up the good work! Ukrainians as well as others were locked up in a prison called USSR from the 1930s if not earlier. The world does not need any more of that. I saw the plowed fields that prevented people from leaving the putrid USSR.

Expand full comment

Two days ago, Michail Shishky and Artem Troitsky gave their interpretation of the corruption of Russian language and culture by Putiniism at a literary panel in Basel. Shishkin compared it to the analogous mechanisms in Germany between 1933 and 1945 and mentionned Thomas Mann’s desperate but relentless efforts to save that language and culture in his radio broadcasts from the USA. Your writings represent an invaluable suppor for these efforts by the Russian elite in exile. Never stop working along this line. Thank you

Expand full comment

Not surprised that I learned more on current developments in Ukraine from Dr Snyder’s post than everything else I’ve read or viewed in the past 48 hours. I suppose this may be considered hyperbole but how I wish Professor Snyder was either our National Security Advisor or Secretary of State.

Expand full comment